Vuvuzela vs. Envioux

[Envioux]

Theme: Touhou

Rules:570 x 190

Vuvuzela's entry



Envioux's entry

[Chaser]

I'm going with Envioux. Both of you needed to blend your render a bit more, but I thought Envioux's had the more appealing background and colours. Didn't go for the text in the top one, either D= (and it's also quite LQ).

[Zyler]

Envioux Gets My Vote.
Although I Like The Rainbow Effect On Vuvuzuelas The Text Just Isn't Clear Enough.

[CircusHead]

Envioux has my vote. Even though both renders are poorly blended with the backround, Envioux's is done just a bit better, and has better colors. Vuvuzela's text didn't really match the sig, the underline is very messy, and the colors are a bit wild. As Chaser pointed out, it's quite LQ, too. I like the rainbow on the right side of the render, and would have liked it a lot more if it matched the backround.

[ascriptmaster]

I'm voting for Vuvuzela, it had some good depth to it. It did have some flaws (part of the render's sleeve was transparent, causing some of the rainbow to show through), but I found the background and its depth better than Envioux's, whose background was blurry overall.

[Link64]

Envioux gets my vote. More appealing colours and my eyes don't stray as much as they do with Vuvuzela's. (Think that may be due to the fact that the sig is quite long and you have placed the render so far to one side. the rest seems to have a negative space feel so a better focal or even focal placement would help)

tl;dr Envioux gets my vote

[Finesse]

Envioux gets mine. The background matches the render a bit more than Vuvuzela's. And like Link64 said, Vuvuzela has too much space. Good work to both of you.

[Dorksta]

I vote for Envioux's, because it flows better. Also same as link64 said my eyes don't stray as much.

[Teabag]

Envioux gets my vote.
I found his tag to be more cleaner.

[SunnyBunny]

Vuvusela's one has some flaws (like the sleeve) and the writing is too hard to read, but on Envioux's one the background doesnt seem to keep the flow of the picture. it is hard to determine who gets my vote but i am going to have to vote for Envioux.