Lucky Line (Voting)

[Link64]

Lucky Line Voting. All entrys with more votes than the Guru Entry will recieve

Please look at the example voting before you post your vote.

Guru Entry

Entry 1

Spoiler

Entry 2

Spoiler

Entry 3

Spoiler

Entry 4

Spoiler

Entry 5

Spoiler

Voting form:

Guru vs Entry1
Guru vs Entry2
Guru vs Entry3
Guru vs Entry4

Example voting:

Spoiler

Guru vs Entry1- I liked the effects and depth more in the gurus entry.
Guru vs Entry2 -reasons
Guru vs Entry3 -reasons

(So basically bold one name in each row you prefer).

[CircusHead]

Guru VS. Entry 1: I vote Guru because the colors are better on the the Guru's entry and the render on Entry 1 is over smudged (I think it's smudge lololol)

Guru VS. Entry 2: On Entry 2, I'm not really sure what the render is on it. It's really blurry and there aren't any cool effects going on.

Guru VS. Entry 3: Entry 3 has a very original concept, imo, and I really like the effects and colors. The render blends to perfection. I think this one has the best chance at beating the Guru.

Guru VS. Entry 4: Entry 4 isn't really even much of a sig, considering all it is, is a render slapped onto a heart backround.

Guru VS. Entry 5: Well, I do kinda like this one, with the firework and all, but other than that, it really doesn't have anything else going on with it.

[ascriptmaster]

Guru vs. Entry 1: Alas, the awesomeness of Kamina could not stand against the vivid effects of the Guru. I am still proud of my work (yes this is my entry), even though it looks kinda flat in comparison. My only regret was positioning the C4D below Kamina's sword the way I did (or even putting that C4D there in the first place XD ).
-- and @ObsessedCrazed, it wasn't smudge. It's Radial Blur.

Guru vs. Entry 2: This entry was so flat that I barely noticed what was meant to be the main focus the first time.

Guru vs. Entry 3: It's a good picture, but it's almost as if the hair faded into the background. Also the fact that the render is oddly-colored (for that of any human being) really was a detriment to how it looked.

Guru vs. Entry 4: The image is cute, but the background is rather bland. Nice lens flare thing behind the render though, props for that.

Guru vs. Entry 5: The effects look nice, but it practically has no background (just a minor gradient) making it bland.

[Hiroko]

Since my text is already bold, I'll put my choices in red. Is that okay?

Guru vs. Entry 1 - Seems like just a lot of smudging, a random C4D thrown in, and just not a lot of effort.

Guru vs. Entry 2 - Colored clouds in background, snowflakes on top, bad render = not a winner. :x

Guru vs. Entry 3 - This one looks like some more effort was put into it. I do find depth and good effects, though the artist could try adding more flow next time.

Guru vs. Entry 4 - I see a clipping mask on top a lens flare or something, and on top of THAT a render. Nothing more.

Guru vs. Entry 5 - The pen tool effect is good, and warrants knowledge of the program. There's nothing else to the sig, though!

[Chaser]

Guru vs Entry 1
Entry 1 needs some work composition wise. Really, it's not at the same level as the guru's piece.

Guru vs Entry 2
Far too LQ and basic to put up much of challenge to the Guru's piece.

Guru vs Entry 3
The render is tipped to a strange angle and there's not much else here adding much flow. The piece doesn't really make sense with the clipping masks and stuffs. Just the composition needs work, it's OK, but the guru's again is a fair bit better.

Guru vs Entry 4
Whilst relatively basic, it's not LQ (which is a relief) and it's kinda cool. Really need something a bit more ambitious to challenge the guru's piece, though.

Guru vs Entry 5
The pentooling and firework is cool. The basics are there; now see if you can expand on them. Sorry, it's gonna have to go to the guru for me!

What can I say sixtyfour, too pro xD

[redd]

Guru vs Entry1: Guru has more appealing look and colors, I don't like entry 1's blur thingy.
Guru vs Entry2: Guru's just looks more sharp and overall more umph, I don't like entry's blurriness or border.
Guru vs Entry3: The entry looks nice, but I simply like Guru's render choice and effects more.
Guru vs Entry4: Entry lacks effects or really anything a sig needs, so Guru on this one.
Guru vs Entry5: I like Guru's effects more, and the entry is a tad too blurry.

[Envioux]

Guru vs Entry1: Guru has more appealing look and colors, I don't like the blur on Entry1.

Guru vs Entry2: Guru's is sharper, has better effects. I don't like Entry2's border, or the blurriness. The render is LQ too.

Guru vs Entry3: The entry looks nice, but I like Guru's effects more. Entry needs more flow.

Guru vs Entry4: Entry isn't bad, per se, it just needs more to it.

Guru vs Entry5: I like Guru's effects more, and the Entry needs more to it. There are not many effects in Entry and it's a bit blurry.

[DoctorPhil]

Guru vs Entry1- I just kind of like the blurring effect and all the warm colors really puts an emphasis on the blue hair I think
Guru vs Entry2- The entry just seems a little boring in comparison to the guru
Guru vs Entry3- Pretty nice entry, I liked the puzzle piece thing pretty cool it just seemed to do a lot more
Guru vs Entry4- The entry was nice but it just seemed a little too simple compared to the guru
Guru vs Entry5- Same thing, the entry was just a little too simple

[HaiImNate]

Guru vs. entry 1: I have to go with the guru on this one. His is more interesting, and the entry's entry is blurred/smudged too much at some parts, and doesn't look all that well.

Guru vs. Entry 2: Entry 2 is more unique imo, but I don't like the colors and the background, and overall image is low quality. I don't like the border either. Very nice, high quality sig. for the guru. I like the red fractals, and the c4ds are okay.

Guru vs. Entry 3: Close, but I have to go with the guru's tag on this one. I really like the nice and vibrant colors in this signature, but I think it would be better with a little more/ lighter lighting, and I pick the guru's because I like the lighting, and I like the light-screened fractals.

Guru vs. Entry 4: The Guru's signature has better effects and it looks like he put more effort into his. Entry 4's tag is plain, and though I do like how it looks it is nothing that special- just a render posted on a background.

Guru vs. Entry 5: I really, really like what Entry 5 did with the pen tools and the text. That looks awesome! Other than that though, it looks plain and the render is blurred where it looks low quality. The guru's signature has more effects; it doesn't look as bare and just overall looks better.

[Zail]

Guru vs. Entry 1: Entry 1 is too messy for my liking, the blurs and smudges on it don't please me much and the colour scheme combined with the blurs make it very bland.
Guru vs. Entry 2: Again low quality and blured makes it in my eyes, bland. The guru's entry is sharper and more clear.
Guru vs. Entry 3: I realy like Entry 3 the artist has made it simple but in a good way, the graphics are amazing but the simplicty of it just passes the line for me, The guru's entry is a bit too complex but still good.
Guru vs. Entry 4: I know this sorta counter acts my last opinion but this entry is way to simple and has next no effects in it, It looks like a render on a background, thats all I see.
Guru vs. Entry 5: I like entry 5, but I am voting for the guru because there is better efects, Entry 5 lacks some effects but don't get me wrong it was close. ^^