Anti-Spiral vs DynastyZero

[Anti-Spiral]

We decided to go broad with video game themes.

Mine

DynastyZero 's

[ascriptmaster]

DynastyZero's was kinda LQ and it looks like the render is facing a different direction from the blur, because of the perspective.

Anti-Spiral's for some reason did not seem to flow well for me, but overall has better effects and is well-blended. I vote for Anti-Spiral.

[CircusHead]

I vote DynastyZero because Anti-Spiral's is very cluttered, and the colors are really messy. DynastyZero's needs work too, but I like how well the render blends into the backround.

[InspectorFish]

I'm not a big fan of either of these really.

Anti-Spiral's has really strange colors and the flow is off.
Dynasty Zero's doesn't have much going on for it either. There is very little depth, not too much in the way of effects, and the render is covered by the background a little bit. The render placement and colors are nice, though.

Still, there is something unique about Anti-Spiral's and it does look a little higher quality.
I guess I'll vote Anti-Spiral but it's a close one.

[Zyler]

Anti-Spiral gets my vote.
The sig really reminds me of Epic Mickey. The rabbit coming out of the ink is a nice touch. Altogether it really looks like it's an inky world..
The effects might be a little off but it's definitely the best of the two

[Sarcasjak]

Anti gets my vote, I like the bold colors and detail.

[Teabag]

Anti Spiral.
His effects suited the sigs theme very nicely.

[Chaser]

Anti-Spiral's is just a tad cooler, but watch the focal to ensure you don't get a cluttered result (which you have). Anti-Spiral by a hair

[KEM720]

I vote for Anti-Spiral's, his sig is the most cohesive of the two. The other is good, but the render doesn't feel as well integrated.

[Cwoek]

AntiSpiral because his render, effects and colour choice went down pretty good.