Go Back   The Nintendo WiFi Community > Nintendo Discussion > Nintendo Wii > WiFi Games (Wii) > Guitar Hero


Guitar Hero All Guitar Hero Games


View Poll Results: guitar hero or rock band?
guitar hero 23 58.97%
rock band 20 51.28%
Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 39. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
(#21)
Old
kieryn's Avatar
Community Leader
kieryn has a brilliant futurekieryn has a brilliant futurekieryn has a brilliant future
Hub: Offline
 
Send a message via MSN to kieryn
Re: guitar hero or rock band???? - 02-16-09

Quote:
Originally Posted by LinkThePhantom View Post
First off, let me just say this: If you're one of those people that think Rock Band is easier than Guitar Hero (Which, granted, is true for the most part) go look up Painkiller or Peace Sells or Panic Attack or Visions. THEN tell me that GH is harder than RB.

Anyway, I personally think Rock Band is better in every aspect. Almost. The graphics are good, as well as the setlist. Going by the Wii versions of both competitors latest releases (GH:WT and RB2), RB2's online is better than WT's, mainly because of the whole 4 Wii's can connect at a time instead of 2 for GH:WT.

Another thing, Rock Band has more songs that people actually like. I didn't listen to many of the songs on either game prior to purchase and I wound up liking Rock Band songs more than Guitar Hero's on a 3:1 ratio.

I mean, seriously, who here can actually say they ENJOYED listening to songs like Escuela de Calor and Do It Again?

Now, if you're into that kind of music, no offense is intended. But I just don't really see why it's in a GH game. It's kinda boring to play.

Getting to the hardware, the drums in Rock Band, especially the RB2 kit, have the advantage of being around longer and are more stable than Guitar Hero's. If you do own a RB2 kit, you'll probably know that:
  • It's velocity sensitive
  • You can use 2 bass drum pedals right out of the box
  • There are ports for cymbals
  • The metal plated foot pedal
Now the cymbals seem pointless, but when plugged in they make up the hi-hat, crash, and ride aspects of a real drum set. Which is kinda cool. In a way.

I still find myself using the guitars that Red Octane makes, though. They seem sturdier.

In conclusion, Rock Band is just more fun than Guitar Hero. Who doesn't like the idea of rocking out with you're friends in a band? Even though it's fake, Rock Band seems to pull it off better.

EDIT: Grr...I just realized I said pretty much the same thing Azurill and ExTrEmE said...Ah, well. A little detail never hurt anyone.
You cant use 2 bass pedals and the drums for rb2 are the worst out of them all.
my friend codes    Friendliest Friendcodian Gold Sticker Red Poster 
Reply With Quote
(#22)
Old
LinkThePhantom's Avatar
東方 Project Addict
LinkThePhantom is on the road to greatnessLinkThePhantom is on the road to greatnessLinkThePhantom is on the road to greatnessLinkThePhantom is on the road to greatnessLinkThePhantom is on the road to greatnessLinkThePhantom is on the road to greatnessLinkThePhantom is on the road to greatnessLinkThePhantom is on the road to greatness
Hub: Offline
 
Send a message via AIM to LinkThePhantom Send a message via MSN to LinkThePhantom Send a message via Skype™ to LinkThePhantom
Re: guitar hero or rock band???? - 02-16-09

Quote:
Originally Posted by kieryn View Post
You cant use 2 bass pedals and the drums for rb2 are the worst out of them all.
...You can't? Huh. I thought you could.

The cymbals for GH:WT kinda threw me off. And RB2 drums aren't that bad, actually.
my friend codes    Friendcodes Socialite Profile Celebrity Bronze Member Red Poster Helpful Helper 
Reply With Quote
(#23)
Old
rockboy's Avatar
Metallica
rockboy will become famous soon enough
Hub: Offline
 
Send a message via AIM to rockboy
Re: guitar hero or rock band???? - 06-18-09

Rock band sucks, guitar hero forever!
my friend codes 
Reply With Quote
(#24)
Old
Gabriel29's Avatar
NSMBW FTW!
Gabriel29 is an exemplary userGabriel29 is an exemplary userGabriel29 is an exemplary userGabriel29 is an exemplary userGabriel29 is an exemplary userGabriel29 is an exemplary userGabriel29 is an exemplary userGabriel29 is an exemplary userGabriel29 is an exemplary user
Hub: Offline
 
Re: guitar hero or rock band???? - 06-18-09

I like both, but there is somethings I like and dislike about both of them.

(Reasons why I like Rock Band)
Rock Band does have some good songs and I like the way the notes are rectangled and how it shows you your percentage on solos! =D I also like the fact that the strum bar to the guitar doesn't make that much noise as the GH guitar! =D

(Reasons why I don't like Rock Band)
The guitar for RB is cool when it doesn't make noise, but it isn't cool for solos. =/ The fret buttons are weird and it is hard for me to get all the notes in solos. =/ I also don't like the fact that the game is WAY to easy for me! D=<

(Reasons why I like Guitar Hero)
I like GH because it was the first game ever to let you play a plastic guitar! I also like it because it is more challenging and they did make some HUGE differences from GH2 to GH3 and because the drum set looks more realistic with the two cymbals at the top! =D

Reasons why I don't like Guitar Hero)
The strumbar to the GH1-Areosmith guitars have been WAY too loud! I couldn't even play at night without making any noise! =/ I also dislike it because most of the songs from Rock Band 2 are in GHWT and because of the sliderbar! It is THE worst thing that they came up with! My sliderbar usually taps itself in the middle of a song and ruins my note streak and my score!



THANKS TO HIROKO FOR THE KICKAZZ SIG!
my friend codes    Profile Celebrity Red Poster 
Reply With Quote
(#25)
Old
TheConduit's Avatar
Senior Member
TheConduit has disabled reputation
Hub: Offline
 
Re: guitar hero or rock band???? - 06-18-09

I like both but I go with GH
my friend codes 
Reply With Quote
(#26)
Old
Banned
Anoshmo is a jewel in the rough
Hub: Offline
 
Re: guitar hero or rock band???? - 06-18-09

Rock Band usually has a better set list but i when it comes to gameplay i love Guitar Hero. You play the Rock Band guitar and you get ticked off because it just fails, though it is quiet. The drums have a horrible bounce-back, and its stupid how they make the notes for it (for example, the blue note will be a high tom, then it will be a crash symbal, then it will be a snare); Guitar Hero actually organized the notes for the drum set, and it has awesome bounce-back. Guitar Hero at least tries to be more realistic, such as having sustained notes while being able to play others, but Rock Band keeps track of solo percentages and all that good stuff that doesnt really matter.

Guitar Hero FTW:)

Last edited by TDG12345; 06-18-09 at 10:17 PM..
my friend codes 
Reply With Quote
(#27)
Old
LoveLucario's Avatar
Lucario is my hero =]
LoveLucario is on the road to greatnessLoveLucario is on the road to greatnessLoveLucario is on the road to greatnessLoveLucario is on the road to greatnessLoveLucario is on the road to greatnessLoveLucario is on the road to greatnessLoveLucario is on the road to greatness
Hub: Offline
 
Send a message via AIM to LoveLucario Send a message via Skype™ to LoveLucario
Re: guitar hero or rock band???? - 06-18-09

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gabriel29 View Post
I like both, but there is somethings I like and dislike about both of them.

(Reasons why I like Rock Band)
Rock Band does have some good songs and I like the way the notes are rectangled and how it shows you your percentage on solos! =D I also like the fact that the strum bar to the guitar doesn't make that much noise as the GH guitar! =D

(Reasons why I don't like Rock Band)
The guitar for RB is cool when it doesn't make noise, but it isn't cool for solos. =/ The fret buttons are weird and it is hard for me to get all the notes in solos. =/ I also don't like the fact that the game is WAY to easy for me! D=<

(Reasons why I like Guitar Hero)
I like GH because it was the first game ever to let you play a plastic guitar! I also like it because it is more challenging and they did make some HUGE differences from GH2 to GH3 and because the drum set looks more realistic with the two cymbals at the top! =D

Reasons why I don't like Guitar Hero)
The strumbar to the GH1-Areosmith guitars have been WAY too loud! I couldn't even play at night without making any noise! =/ I also dislike it because most of the songs from Rock Band 2 are in GHWT and because of the sliderbar! It is THE worst thing that they came up with! My sliderbar usually taps itself in the middle of a song and ruins my note streak and my score!

You need the sound of the strums to keep your time. I always make on strum significantly louder than the others when I'm in a song with double strumming. It is very helpful in Metallica. When I play RockBand I can't keep a X4 on the RockBand guitar because I can't hear the strums.
my friend codes    Sketch Artist Red Poster The Man of the Hour 
Reply With Quote
(#28)
Old
XxDemonic_SlayerxX's Avatar
On a break...........
XxDemonic_SlayerxX has a reputation beyond reputeXxDemonic_SlayerxX has a reputation beyond reputeXxDemonic_SlayerxX has a reputation beyond reputeXxDemonic_SlayerxX has a reputation beyond repute
Hub: Offline
 
Re: guitar hero or rock band???? - 06-18-09

Both..Anyways Rockband is made by the same creator's of Guitar Hero...
my friend codes    Bronze Member 
Reply With Quote
(#29)
Old
LoveLucario's Avatar
Lucario is my hero =]
LoveLucario is on the road to greatnessLoveLucario is on the road to greatnessLoveLucario is on the road to greatnessLoveLucario is on the road to greatnessLoveLucario is on the road to greatnessLoveLucario is on the road to greatnessLoveLucario is on the road to greatness
Hub: Offline
 
Send a message via AIM to LoveLucario Send a message via Skype™ to LoveLucario
Re: guitar hero or rock band???? - 06-18-09

Quote:
Originally Posted by XxDemonic_SlayerxX View Post
Both..Anyways Rockband is made by the same creator's of Guitar Hero...
But they failed at making a decent looking notechart and setlists for RockBand :P.
my friend codes    Sketch Artist Red Poster The Man of the Hour 
Reply With Quote
(#30)
Old
TDG12345's Avatar
`
TDG12345 is an exemplary userTDG12345 is an exemplary userTDG12345 is an exemplary userTDG12345 is an exemplary userTDG12345 is an exemplary userTDG12345 is an exemplary userTDG12345 is an exemplary userTDG12345 is an exemplary userTDG12345 is an exemplary userTDG12345 is an exemplary userTDG12345 is an exemplary user
Hub: Offline
 
Send a message via MSN to TDG12345
Re: guitar hero or rock band???? - 06-18-09

Guitar Hero = Better

<3
my friend codes    Elite Poster Bronze Member Good Grammar Award The End of the Line Profile Celebrity The Man of the Hour Helpful Helper Warmest Welcomer Friendcodes Socialite Protector of the People 
Reply With Quote
Reply

Tags
band, guitar, guitar hero rock band, hero, rock

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Rock Band 2 or Guitar Hero: World Tour? Liquid_Nitrogen WiFi Games (Wii) 26 02-16-09 03:51 PM
Guitar Hero or Rock Band? Imjustakid Nintendo Talk 20 01-02-09 03:55 AM
Whats better GH or RB? (Guitar Hero or Rock Band) JakeO Nintendo Talk 16 09-17-08 01:36 AM
Wii Music won't be phased by Guitar Hero and Rock Band. Büdge007 News and Notes 18 08-12-08 07:58 PM
Does Rock Band Let you Play with Guitar Hero Guitars!! falco0 Non-WiFi Games (Wii) 4 08-02-08 03:22 AM



vBulletin®, Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2005 - 2009 friendcodes.com. We are not affiliated with Nintendo.

-->