Go Back   The Nintendo WiFi Community > Nintendo Discussion > Nintendo Talk


Nintendo Talk Talk about general Nintendo-related topics here, such as your favourite game characters and series.


View Poll Results: do you believe reviews
yes 10 34.48%
no 19 65.52%
Voters: 29. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
(#21)
Old
Banned
nintendoman101 is an exemplary usernintendoman101 is an exemplary usernintendoman101 is an exemplary usernintendoman101 is an exemplary usernintendoman101 is an exemplary usernintendoman101 is an exemplary usernintendoman101 is an exemplary usernintendoman101 is an exemplary usernintendoman101 is an exemplary usernintendoman101 is an exemplary user
Hub: Offline
 
Send a message via MSN to nintendoman101 Send a message via Skype™ to nintendoman101
Re: who else thinks reviews are wrong? - 08-30-08

Quote:
Originally Posted by way2nice4ds View Post
SMS? what does that stand for?
Super Mario Sunshine.
my friend codes    Member Appreciation The Conduit: 2nd Silver Member Retro Gamer Red Poster 
Reply With Quote
(#22)
Old
Nobody's Avatar
Has a HUGE Wii ladies! ;)
Nobody is an exemplary userNobody is an exemplary userNobody is an exemplary userNobody is an exemplary userNobody is an exemplary userNobody is an exemplary userNobody is an exemplary userNobody is an exemplary userNobody is an exemplary user
Hub: Offline
 
Re: who else thinks reviews are wrong? - 08-30-08

Oh, that game was Awesome! My favorite Mario to date! (I don't have a Wii so I never tried Galaxy)
my friend codes    Silver Member Red Poster Kerbert Xela - Professor Layton & Luke 
Reply With Quote
(#23)
Old
Fearme's Avatar
Prepare to be terminated
Fearme is a name known to allFearme is a name known to all
Hub: Offline
 
Send a message via AIM to Fearme
Re: who else thinks reviews are wrong? - 08-30-08

Quote:
Originally Posted by way2nice4ds View Post
Oh, that game was Awesome! My favorite Mario to date! (I don't have a Wii so I never tried Galaxy)
If you had gotten Galaxy, SMS wouldn't compare.
my friend codes 
Reply With Quote
(#24)
Old
Banned
nintendoman101 is an exemplary usernintendoman101 is an exemplary usernintendoman101 is an exemplary usernintendoman101 is an exemplary usernintendoman101 is an exemplary usernintendoman101 is an exemplary usernintendoman101 is an exemplary usernintendoman101 is an exemplary usernintendoman101 is an exemplary usernintendoman101 is an exemplary user
Hub: Offline
 
Send a message via MSN to nintendoman101 Send a message via Skype™ to nintendoman101
Re: who else thinks reviews are wrong? - 08-30-08

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fearme View Post
If you had gotten Galaxy, SMS wouldn't compare.
true.
my friend codes    Member Appreciation The Conduit: 2nd Silver Member Retro Gamer Red Poster 
Reply With Quote
(#25)
Old
Nobody's Avatar
Has a HUGE Wii ladies! ;)
Nobody is an exemplary userNobody is an exemplary userNobody is an exemplary userNobody is an exemplary userNobody is an exemplary userNobody is an exemplary userNobody is an exemplary userNobody is an exemplary userNobody is an exemplary user
Hub: Offline
 
Re: who else thinks reviews are wrong? - 08-30-08

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fearme View Post
If you had gotten Galaxy, SMS wouldn't compare.
But I don't (no money for a Wii) so SMS is my fav.
my friend codes    Silver Member Red Poster Kerbert Xela - Professor Layton & Luke 
Reply With Quote
(#26)
Old
Fearme's Avatar
Prepare to be terminated
Fearme is a name known to allFearme is a name known to all
Hub: Offline
 
Send a message via AIM to Fearme
Re: who else thinks reviews are wrong? - 08-30-08

Quote:
Originally Posted by way2nice4ds View Post
But I don't (no money for a Wii) so SMS is my fav.
Here's a million bucks. Use them wisely.
my friend codes 
Reply With Quote
(#27)
Old
Azurill's Avatar
I made an EP. It awesome.
Azurill is an exemplary userAzurill is an exemplary userAzurill is an exemplary userAzurill is an exemplary userAzurill is an exemplary userAzurill is an exemplary userAzurill is an exemplary userAzurill is an exemplary userAzurill is an exemplary userAzurill is an exemplary userAzurill is an exemplary user
Hub: Offline
 
Send a message via AIM to Azurill Send a message via Skype™ to Azurill
Re: who else thinks reviews are wrong? - 08-30-08

Wow, you guys are complaining because a six-year-old game isn't everybody's favorite GCN title.

In fact, even the original topic for this thread was an absolute joke.

Guys, if the reviews weren't true, they wouldn't be making them. It's that simple.
my friend codes    Silver Member The End of the Line Profile Celebrity Red Poster 
Reply With Quote
(#28)
Old
Suntro's Avatar
The Jarate Master
Suntro is an exemplary userSuntro is an exemplary userSuntro is an exemplary userSuntro is an exemplary userSuntro is an exemplary userSuntro is an exemplary userSuntro is an exemplary userSuntro is an exemplary userSuntro is an exemplary userSuntro is an exemplary userSuntro is an exemplary user
Hub: Offline
 
Re: who else thinks reviews are wrong? - 08-30-08

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fearme View Post
If you had gotten Galaxy, SMS wouldn't compare.
I bought Galaxy, got 20 stars and then never played again. Instead, I went through my Gamecube games found Windwaker and SMS which I had never beaten then beat them both. I still haven't beaten galaxy.

Anyways, I think most reviewers are overgenerous. No game will ever deserve a 10/10 because it will be beaten by something else soon after. One of my favorite reviewers is Yahtzee from Zero Punctuation. He doesn't give a numeric score but he points out all the games flaws and highlights.
my friend codes    Gold Member Elite Poster Sketch Artist The Living Dead Award 
Reply With Quote
(#29)
Old
Fearme's Avatar
Prepare to be terminated
Fearme is a name known to allFearme is a name known to all
Hub: Offline
 
Send a message via AIM to Fearme
Re: who else thinks reviews are wrong? - 08-30-08

Quote:
Originally Posted by Suntro View Post
I bought Galaxy, got 20 stars and then never played again. Instead, I went through my Gamecube games found Windwaker and SMS which I had never beaten then beat them both. I still haven't beaten galaxy.

Anyways, I think most reviewers are overgenerous. No game will ever deserve a 10/10 because it will be beaten by something else soon after. One of my favorite reviewers is Yahtzee from Zero Punctuation. He doesn't give a numeric score but he points out all the games flaws and highlights.
Truthfully, I only got to 50 or is it 60 stars, just to get the spaceship running. I'm not a great fan of 3D platformers, but I think overall, Galaxy was a cooler experience than SMS... that is while it lasted.
my friend codes 
Reply With Quote
(#30)
Old
OmegaSlayer's Avatar
Elite Twilight Commander
OmegaSlayer has a spectacular aura about
Hub: Offline
 
Re: who else thinks reviews are wrong? - 08-30-08

Not entirely, but yes in a way. Reviews are reviews. They're not telling you to jump off a cliff if your favorite game gets a 1 out of 5, 10, or whatever. It's just a guide that tell you what will you expect in this game in a general, unbiased (mostly hard to accomplished that) viewpoint. And half the times, they are quite true.

Lets take Shadow the Hedgehog for an example. SdtH gets a calm score around 6 or lower from most reviewers because the game still has its fair elements from previous 3D Sonic games, but it was crap up with bad gameplay (most running and use of guns), cheesy missions that are heavily boring and/or time consuming, and a story line that has quite horrible voice-acting. And you know what, I played it, and the reviewer wasn't lying one bit of it.

Every game isn't going to be enjoyable to everybody, and reviews are one of those people that can express that and guide people about their experiences with it. Besides, if you know a review is wrong, why bother listening to it? You know it's true that the game is good to you, so why make a commotion about one's opinion that is mostly not true to your view? You'll have to deal with that in the future or you're not going to respect opinions anytime soon.


my friend codes 
Reply With Quote
Reply

Tags
reviews, thinks, wrong

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Who here thinks PA is poo xD davidthan Nintendo Talk 1 05-10-08 01:48 AM
Who thinks there good? Darloiu Super Smash Bros Brawl 47 01-17-08 05:47 PM
Who thinks xSouRx Pokémon Diamond/Pearl/Platinum 9 12-01-07 02:47 AM
Why people critcize games, and why they are wrong, wrong, wrong Spacepirate091 General Discussions 14 10-14-07 12:30 PM
Who thinks I will be a good mod? InJoyAndSorrow Fun & Games 1 06-19-07 02:00 AM



vBulletin®, Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2005 - 2009 friendcodes.com. We are not affiliated with Nintendo.

-->