Brawl vs. Melee

[-Matt-]

Do you guy's like melee or Brawl more? I don't have melee but if it's better I might get it, vote now!

[jeumaitre]

Definently Brawl. Melee was a good game and all, but Brawl topped it in every way.

[Sihk_Sketch]

Brawl has a lot going for it, but I was dissapointed in it. I got bored of it fast, but Melee took years to tire of.

[Hiroko]

I have them both, and I have to say that Brawl is like a beefed-up version of Melee. Melee doesn't cope with laggy multiplayer (due to the lack of), though.

[FLAME-RESISTANT]So... I think I'll go with Brawl.[/FLAME-RESISTANT]

[Dray]

Brawl is much more better

[WART 7]

Originally Posted by jeumaitre

Definently Brawl. Melee was a good game and all, but Brawl topped it in every way.

I agree, Melee was awsome, but Brawl is so much better. Brawl's gameplay is smoother and easier to play. Like, I was doing pretty good on Day 1 of Brawl's launch. There's many more things to do, and more characters and stages. Rather than clones. Now there's online play. What tops it off is that you can play as Wario. :D

[Zarif]

Of course people will vote brawl. Nintendo made Brawl as a better version of Melee.

[Cynical]

Originally Posted by zarif

Of course people will vote brawl. Nintendo made Brawl as a better version of Melee.

Better version as in Graphics and details yes, but in terms of gameplay, Melee definitely takes that away...

lol... Melee no doubt, I just really don't want to go into details... BUT OH WELL

Why Melee is better!
-Their seems to be always fast paced battles compared to Brawl, A match with a Fox and Falco normally lasts 1-2m lol
-Certain Techniques such as L-canceling, wave-dashing/landing, SHFFL'ing, and others!
-Teching/Ukemi (in Brawl terms) is way easier and much more reliable in Melee
-Combos are more respected due to the complexity and stuff
-Most characters are way better in Melee before Brawl, Fox was unique with his JC shining and such, Falco had Shine Pillaring and SHL, Marth was known for his extremely large grab range and attacks which led to combos and such (way easier), Peach was known for her Down smash (lol), IC for their unique grab combos that were much cooler than Brawl WOBBLING *cough*, their were many others, but I can't explain them at the moment (My main characters are Bowser and Luigi in Melee).
- Skill was certainly a factor in Melee, sure you can spam, but in Melee... you are definitely not getting away with it unlike Brawl.
- Anyone can chain grab (dunno about the tether characters)
- Edge-hogging techniques were more easier in Melee such as intercepting and such... and since not that much characters had sweet spot edge grabbing, they could be hit before they grab the ledge, unlike Brawl

The list can go on..., but lets just leave it at that

Brawl is not a bad game, but more as an "easier" version of Melee... to me, but minus important AT's

[kirby5292]

Originally Posted by LittleMoogle

Better version as in Graphics and details yes, but in terms of gameplay, Melee definitely takes that away...

lol... Melee no doubt, I just really don't want to go into details... BUT OH WELL

Why Melee is better!
-Their seems to be always fast paced battles compared to Brawl, A match with a Fox and Falco normally lasts 1-2m lol
-Certain Techniques such as L-canceling, wave-dashing/landing, SHFFL'ing, and others!
-Teching/Ukemi (in Brawl terms) is way easier and much more reliable in Melee
-Combos are more respected due to the complexity and stuff
-Most characters are way better in Melee before Brawl, Fox was unique with his JC shining and such, Falco had Shine Pillaring and SHL, Marth was known for his extremely large grab range and attacks which led to combos and such (way easier), Peach was known for her Down smash (lol), IC for their unique grab combos that were much cooler than Brawl WOBBLING *cough*, their were many others, but I can't explain them at the moment (My main characters are Bowser and Luigi in Melee).
- Skill was certainly a factor in Melee, sure you can spam, but in Melee... you are definitely not getting away with it unlike Brawl.
- Anyone can chain grab (dunno about the tether characters)
- Edge-hogging techniques were more easier in Melee such as intercepting and such... and since not that much characters had sweet spot edge grabbing, they could be hit before they grab the ledge, unlike Brawl

The list can go on..., but lets just leave it at that

Brawl is not a bad game, but more as an "easier" version of Melee... to me, but minus important AT's

thankyou melee is way better:cool:

[Tax]

Melee.
Why?
Because.