Pokemon Heart Gold/Soul Silver Starter?

[ShadowDragon]

Possibly too early, but doesn't matter. I personally can't decide between Cyndaquil and Totodile, haha.

[Cameron]

In Gold, Silver and Crystal I chose Totodile, so I think I'll continue my tradition.

[L]

I pick Cyndaquil for a Starter, in Pokemon Gold/Silver/Crystal Version that I played before, Cyndaquil have been with me on the adventure of the Johto Region and I notice that I could beat this game just like last time but with new skills for battling opponents that got new skills too.

[Darrk]

Quilava will rock the 2nd and 7th gym - RARRRRRR! :D

[saladmence]

totodile may fave

[Envioux]

I have always chosen a water pokemon and a fire pokemon. Reason being, my brother would always ask for the version that I didn't get, and never played it. I would always choose a fire on his game, and a water on mine. I just prefer the tradition, therefore I'm going with what I did back then. HeartGold = Cyndaquil, SoulSilver = Totodile.

[SoccerLuigi]

I remember choosing Cyndaquil as my starter when I played it years ago. I don't see why not to choose it again.

[Zel-EX]

Same as you, can't decide between Cyndaquil or Totodile. I like Typloshion the most, but I need a good Surfer.

[Terra]

probably cyndaquil because i just like fire types :3

[Hybrid Truth]

I started of with totadile in Gold but now that I'm older I realized that I don't like its stats so, Cyndaquil for its nice sp att